Searching 5,000+ NDE accounts…
Finding relevant experiences and synthesising an answer
Searching 5,000+ NDE accounts…
Finding relevant experiences and synthesising an answer
What NDEs say
The soul is not choosing suffering for its own sake. It's choosing the kind of deep, transformative growth that only contrast can teach, a learning that happens at the level of being, not intellect.
Many people who have had near-death experiences say that souls choose difficult lives because illness and grief are among the greatest teachers we have [1]. One woman described how she came into an abusive family, going to school with bald spots because her hair was being pulled out, bleeding and bruised [4]. She said that at first, if someone had told her she chose that experience, it would have made her really angry. But from the perspective she gained during her NDE, she came to see it differently: no one can ever hurt the precious soul itself, and she may have come as the pivotal person in the family who breaks the chains and changes everything [4].
What these experiencers describe is not a soul choosing pain for pain's sake, but choosing contrast as a tool for growth [3]. The soul is not after a small experience of physical wealth or an easy life. It's after deep, eternal, true expansion of being, which is the deepening of love and joy [3]. This kind of learning happens at the soul level, not intellectually, by being something rather than just thinking about it [3]. Everything we go through, even extreme cases of abuse and loss, is described as a lesson for developing at a higher soul level [2].
This does not erase the reality of your suffering or make it okay that terrible things happen. What it suggests is that your soul may have known something your human self could not: that this particular struggle would open a door to growth, compassion, or strength that no easier path could offer. The circumstances evolved to a place where you could learn these lessons [1]. Your pain is real, and so is the possibility that it serves a purpose larger than the moment you are living through.
This synthesis was generated from real NDE accounts in our archive. It is not medical or spiritual advice. Accounts are first-person testimonies — reported experiences, not verified facts.
The accounts cited above, with the relevant quotes
Additional accounts from the archive related to this question
Read the in-depth article
If souls choose their lives for growth, why would anyone choose abuse, illness, or tragedy?
“So the reason we're here is to learn. And learning is hard. And some days we just want to give up. I call them my toddler temper tantrum moments, you know, where I'm like, "This is too hard. Like, who in their right mind would ever choose this life?" But it's not you as a human that's using it. So people get confused there. They think, you know, why would a child ever choose to be abused? Why would I, would anyone be like, choose to be in a massive tragedy or something like that? Your human self doesn't choose. That's chosen before you come here.”59:09
Tales Of Resilience · Feb 4, 2024 · 4K views
Tia Renee · Feb 28, 2024 · 528 views
About Freedom Show · May 2, 2024 · 6K views
NDE Diary · Dec 20, 2024 · 89K views
The Other Side NDE · Jun 10, 2023 · 2.3M views
Love Covered Life Podcast · Feb 15, 2023 · 4K views
Love Covered Life Podcast · Mar 3, 2026 · 2K views
NDE Radio with Lee Witting · Dec 1, 2020 · 10K views
Tia Renee · Sep 13, 2024 · 14K views
Pegi Robinson - NDE TV · Jan 13, 2022 · 5K views
Love Covered Life Podcast · Jul 28, 2026 · 1K views
IANDS · May 9, 2024 · 5K views
Beyond with Heather Tesch · Jan 1, 2026 · 22K views
Afterlife Atlas · Jun 16, 2023 · 439 views
Was this answer helpful?